star_killer: (09)
star_killer ([personal profile] star_killer) wrote in [community profile] sortinghat_rp2012-01-12 09:04 pm

[01]

You were all fools for being against him. Now what’s going to happen to us? We’ll die off. He had the right idea, but would anyone actually listen?

My Master... he says that Dark Lord will be back. And when he does, I hope none of you expect forgiveness. What we’re- you’re becoming is sick. All a bunch of Muggle-sympathising idiots!

We are the future, not them. And if we don’t do something then they’ll end up being the end of us.
thornsofoglogoth: (& Neutral)

[personal profile] thornsofoglogoth 2012-01-23 03:55 am (UTC)(link)
Perhaps not, though if presented with logical evidence that Dumbledore was dead, I might believe it. Whether I believe in the method claimed by the media is a secondary part of the equation. Questions would need to be answered, but I would likely still harbour some doubt of his continued existence if he abandoned this school in such a sudden way; especially in a time of need.

Essentially, given his sudden disappearance and lack of communication, have you no niggling doubt behind it all that he may have either abandoned you or been killed? Perhaps the Ministry is hiding a secret weapon and attempting to pass it off as a child. After all, I don't quite understand what the Dark Lord intends to achieve by hiding so thoroughly from his own followers and the rest of the world at this point in time, given his power even at the time of the incident. If you have heard from him, it would explain your steadfast loyalty, but otherwise, how has he been silenced? Would that have been the fault of a child? I find it just as implausible.